Stach Rechtsanwälte Logo

Contracts via WhatsApp: When Are Digital Messages Legally Binding?

A brief “Agreed” via WhatsApp, a price confirmation by text message or an acceptance by E-Mail: contracts are increasingly concluded digitally in everyday life. But when does such communication give rise to a legally binding agreement? And can these messages serve as evidence in the event of a dispute? As a general rule, the same principles apply to digital declarations of intent as to other expressions of intent. Whether a contract has been concluded, however, depends on the specific exchange between the parties.

Contracts Do Not Require a Signature

Pursuant to Art. 1 para. 1 of the Swiss Code of Obligations (CO), a contract is concluded through the mutual expression of intent by the parties. Such expressions of intent may be made expressly or impliedly (Art. 1 para. 2 CO). As a general rule, a contract is not subject to any specific formal requirements unless the law prescribes otherwise (Art. 11 CO). In the absence of statutory formal requirements, contracts may therefore be concluded orally, in writing or through digital means of communication. Accordingly, an agreement reached via WhatsApp, SMS or E-Mail can be just as legally binding as a signed contract.

The decisive factor is whether the parties have agreed on the essential terms of the contract and intended to enter into a binding obligation. The parties’ actual mutual intention is considered first. If this cannot be established, their declarations must be interpreted according to their wording, context and the circumstances of the case. For example, if a person offers to sell a specific vehicle for CHF 12,000 via WhatsApp and the prospective buyer replies, “Agreed, I’ll take it”, a valid purchase agreement may already have been concluded. By contrast, statements such as “That sounds interesting” do not necessarily constitute a binding acceptance. The preceding exchange of messages must always be taken into account.

When Are Digital Messages Insufficient?

The principle of freedom of form is subject to certain exceptions. The law prescribes specific formal requirements for certain legal transactions. For example, a non-competition clause in an employment relationship must be agreed upon in writing pursuant to Art. 340 CO. A mere WhatsApp message is insufficient for this purpose. As a general rule, a handwritten signature or a legally recognised qualified electronic signature is required (Art. 14 CO). In addition, the statutory requirements for the validity of a non-competition clause must be fulfilled (Art. 340 para. 2 CO).

Similarly, contracts for the purchase of real estate must be executed in the form of a notarised public deed pursuant to Art. 216 CO. An agreement reached via WhatsApp cannot replace this statutory form.

Furthermore, the parties may agree that a contract will only become effective upon the signing of a written document. If the parties intend to comply with a specific form, it is presumed that they do not wish to be bound until that form has been fulfilled (Art. 16 para. 1 CO). In such cases, a prior digital agreement is not necessarily binding.

WhatsApp Messages as Evidence

Digital messages can not only establish contracts but may also serve as evidence in legal proceedings. Pursuant to Art. 177 of the Swiss Code of Civil Procedure (CPC), electronic files qualify as documentary evidence insofar as they are capable of proving legally relevant facts. This includes, in particular, WhatsApp messages and emails.

A chat history may, for example, serve as evidence of an agreed purchase price or a payment commitment. However, the authenticity and completeness of the messages are decisive. If the authenticity of a document is disputed, the party relying on it must generally prove its authenticity (Art. 178 CPC).

Conclusion

Under Swiss law, contracts may generally also be validly concluded via WhatsApp, SMS or E-Mail. A handwritten signature is not always required. What matters is whether, in the specific context, the message demonstrates that the parties have reached an agreement on the essential terms of the contract and intended to enter into a binding obligation.

Nevertheless, statutory formal requirements must be observed. Digital messages may also serve as evidence in the event of a dispute. Companies and private individuals should therefore communicate carefully, even when using seemingly informal messages, and retain relevant correspondence. Even a simple “Agreed” can have legal consequences, although this is not necessarily the case.

Michael Kummer
Michael Kummer 
Senior Partner 

kummer@stach.ch
+41 (0)71 278 78 28

Focus

Contracts via WhatsApp: When Are Digital Messages Legally Binding?

When a company goes bankrupt: When must funds received be repaid?

Speed Checks from the Air: When Is Drone Footage Admissible as Evidence?

All Focus-News